Between a half and two-thirds of adults who see a psychiatrist for an ADHD diagnosis are prescribed medication, Jagadheesan said. However, he stressed that many people seeking an ADHD diagnosis never made it to a psychiatrist, and instead received non-pharmaceutical health help from a GP or psychologist.
“Not everybody needs medication, even though it has high efficacy,” he said. “There is a proportion of individuals for whom it is better for them to be managing their skills and making lifestyle changes.”
Ritalin is among the medications prescribed to treat ADHD.Credit:Glen McCurtayne
An influential 2018 review published in Lancet Psychiatry found strong evidence for the effectiveness of psychostimulants as treatment for ADHD. However, the available data only allowed for researchers to assess the impact of medication for up to 12 weeks. It concluded methylphenidate should be the preferred drug for children with ADHD while dexamphetamine was preferred for adults. But drug therapy was more effective in children than adults overall.
Prescription rates for ADHD medication have historically been the subject of controversy, such as when the number of Australian children on medication increased nine-fold between 1990 and 2000.
But psychiatrist Dr Roger Paterson, a board member of the Australian ADHD Professionals Association, argued the prescription figures actually indicated psychiatrists were being judicious with issuing scripts and showed most people with the condition were not on any medication.
Loading
“The absolute number of people taking stimulant medication increases from year to year, but it is still way under the expected prevalence rates for children and adults,” said Paterson, who has received funding to attend educational conferences from pharmaceutical companies that manufacture ADHD medication.
It is estimated that about one in 20 Australian children have ADHD, and about 2.5 per cent of adults, although not all of these people will have received a diagnosis.
“[It is] correct that we can’t tell by [prescription numbers] alone that there is overuse in ADHD medication. We will also not know whether the medications are actually being used to treat ADHD or are used ‘off-label’,” said Rae Thomas, an associate professor in the Centre for Research in Evidence-Based Practice at Bond University. However, she said there was a “growing body of evidence suggesting ADHD is possibly over-diagnosed”.
A 2021 Australian review of research, published in JAMA Psychiatry and co-authored by Thomas, found “evidence of ADHD overdiagnosis and overtreatment in children and adolescents”, particularly those with milder symptoms, but noted evidence gaps remained, and future research was needed.
Loading
Ongoing research by the same team published this year has used data from two age cohorts in the Longitudinal Study of Australian Children to demonstrate that ADHD diagnoses have increased while parents’ reports of ADHD-related behaviours remained relatively stable, also raising questions about overdiagnosis.
Early next month, the first Australian Evidence-Based Clinical Guideline for ADHD will be published by the Australian ADHD Professionals Association, the first endorsed by the federal government’s National Health and Medical Research Council.
It will contain 132 recommendations for the diagnosis, treatment and support of people with ADHD across their lifespan.
A 2019 Deloitte Access Economics report estimated the annual cost of untreated ADHD in Australia at $20 billion, more than half of which was modelled productivity losses.
Jagadheesan said the guidelines could not be coming at a better time. Patients seeking a diagnosis are routinely waiting months to see a psychiatrist, as mental health services are strained by the impact of the pandemic. He is hopeful that a focus on ADHD could lead to a dedicated funding commitment.
“We need better training for other disciplines, not necessarily psychiatrists or paediatricians, so a better assessment process can happen to determine if there is a need for a referral,” he said.
The Morning Edition newsletter is our guide to the day’s most important and interesting stories, analysis and insights. Sign up here.
Originally published at Sydney News HQ
No comments:
Post a Comment